Updates from The Forum

Add your name to our electronic mailing list to receive news updates from The Forum.






Print E-mail
legislative-frameworkTHE NEED FOR AN OVER-ARCHING LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORK FOR SOCIAL WELFARE AND DEVELOPMENT SERVICES IN SOUTH AFRICA

Discussion Document: Draft March 2010

The preparation and ongoing development of this discussion document is further to a resolution of the NWF members meeting of October 2009, where members resolved to:

“Call on government to work with the sector to review of the National Welfare Act of 1997. Alternatively, we call on government to work with the sector to develop a new statute to act as a reference point for the provision of social welfare and developmental social services in South Africa”

The full text of the resolution can be found here:
http://www.forum.org.za/Summary-of-Resolutions-NWF-Policy-Positions-October-2009

This is the second version of a very short call for interest published here:
http://www.forum.org.za/policy/res131

It is presently a discussion document and input from all affected stakeholders is encouraged. Kindly send any comments you may have to Karen Peters on This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it or by fax 011 4920371. Karen Peters, Jackie Loffell and Rajesh Latchman have prepared this current draft for and on behalf of the National Welfare Forum (NWF).

Introduction

A compelling need currently exists for the development of a legislative framework for social welfare and development services in South Africa. Thousands of civil society organisations provide core services in this arena, providing and contributing to critical care for our people and communities. Right now, there is an absence of legislation regarding the functioning of the sector as a whole, including the partnership between government and non-profit organisations which is crucial to service delivery. The spelling out of the nature and operation of this partnership would be a critical aspect of a new legislative framework . The proposed legislation will also serve to outline the relationships between the national development agenda and the impact this has for the implementation of a developmental state. It is impossible to suggest that a developmental state can be built in the absence of visionary legislation that defines the human development objectives of the country.

A brief background


The pre-1994 framework that governed the relationship specifically between social service organisations and government was set out in two Apartheid laws - the National Welfare Act of 1978 and the Fundraising Act of 1978. Between them these pieces of legislation entrenched racial discrimination and increased the control of the state over community-based organisations and NGOs, subjecting organisations to draconian search, seizure and interrogation. Given the abuse of these Acts to entrench the Apartheid system and to suppress anti-government activities, all but a few clauses were quickly repealed after the coming of democracy. While this action removed major distortions in, and abuses of, the sector, there remains an absence of appropriate legislation to clarify the responsibilities of the social welfare sector, to identify the responsibilities of the three spheres of government in this regard, to guide the relationship between the Department of Social Development and non-profit organisations, and to provide for the funding of these organisations and their projects. Also absent is proper provision for the registration of social welfare organisations - as opposed to registration for NPOs in general via the Non-Profit Organisations Act, which covers civil society organisations in every sector. It does not address itself to the planning needs of the social welfare sector, or to its need for specific controls to address fraud and to protect vulnerable groups. In short, this proposed legislation picks up from where the White Paper for Social Welfare, 1997 left off. Given that government has not moved forward on that landmark policy proposal, it is vital for our ongoing developmental state agenda, that we immediately revisit the key outcomes of the 1997 process and move forward with urgency to ensure we fulfil our Constitutional mandate to build a better life for all.

The basic proposal

The development of an appropriate legal framework could have a huge and positive impact on the social welfare and development sector as a start and contribute to the overall objective of building a developmental state. Such a framework could address areas such as:
  • Defining the scope of the social welfare responsibilities of national, provincial and local government,
  • In relation to a developmental state agenda and the realisation of the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs),
  • And framed by the imperatives of addressing the ever increasing poverty and inequality in South Africa without,
  • Having to bear the economic risks of a constantly growing debt burden that the current silo-based cash grants social security system engenders.
  • It will also provide a holistic legislative framework for the location of the National Development Agency (NDA), the National Lottery Distribution Fund (NLDTF) and specific allocations from Official development assistance (ODA), congruent with the developmental state agenda and,
  • Ensure maximisation of the budgetary imperatives for such earmarked development funds.
  • Making specific provision for the registration of organisations delivering services to vulnerable groups, with a view to eliminating overlap and filling gaps in the service system.
  • Preventing and responding to fraud, corruption, and malpractice within the sector.
  • Setting the parameters for the partnership between government and NPOs in service delivery, including the manner in which such organisations are to be funded and developing partnerships for graduation of social security grantees.
  • Statutory provision for genuinely consultative processes between government and civil society for the planning and implementation of services.
  • A framework for ongoing monitoring, evaluation and constant service innovation in relation to meeting the needs of a developmental state.
  • Finally, such a framework provides a valuable tool for lessons of managing and implementing large scale state driven developmental initiatives, that can be leveraged across other sectors such as the environment, tourism etc.
Such a legislative framework should be designed to incorporate:
  • Human resources policies that relate to critical issues, such as the recruitment and retention of social workers in the NGO sector
  • Financing strategies for the sector including costing models and parity between government and the non-profit sector.
  • And various other operational imperatives that could be addressed via regulations as well.

A way forward

Given the critical services provided by this sector to the most vulnerable people in our society, there is an urgent need to develop a new and better legislative environment for the social welfare and development sector.

One aspect of immediate action required by government, is the implementation of Act No. 3 of 2001: Advisory Board on Social Development Act, 2001, “To provide for a national advisory structure in the social development sector with the aim of building and consolidating partnership between government and civil society…” Read more here

 

The fact that this matter has been outstanding since 2001 is unacceptable and the immediate appointment of the board will serve as an act of good faith by the state in giving the developmental social services sector and indication of its commitment to provide an enabling environment for their continued efforts towards building a developmental state.

The NWF would like to propose as a sector, we start to develop this new framework and engage in advocacy relating to the areas that need urgent attention. We ask that you participate in this process, and join us as in creating a reference group, contributing ideas and content, hosting dialogue workshops and work collaboratively to advance the process to develop this legislation.

We also re-iterate our call to government to work with the civil society sector to take forward this important development imperative for South Africa.

pdf Click here to download PDF version. 142.40 Kb




Bookmark this article:
Reddit!Del.icio.us!Google!Facebook!Netscape!StumbleUpon!Newsvine!Yahoo!Free social bookmarking plugins and extensions for Joomla! websites!
 
< Prev